Coincidence or Luck or What?
Watching the Wales v New Zealand rugby match today, I was left musing on the question of ‘nature or nurture’, which every parent comes up against in their lives. Having recently become a grandfather to two fine boys, with another grandchild on the way, I often wonder how the genes of any family work through the generations, and the constant references to a Welsh player today called James Botham intrigued me. I know that name, and indeed any person of my age will have grown up with the exploits of a certain I. T. Botham on cricket pitches in the 70’s and 80’s. Amazingly, this young Welsh rugby player, Man of the Match today, is the grandson of the great Ian, and clearly has inherited some powerful sporting genes.
This took me on to thinking about musical heritage too. Where does talent, or genius, come from, and how is it shared out? Where did Mozart’s extraordinary genius come from? Why did so many truly great instrumentalists emerge from the Jewish diaspora in the middle of the 20th century? Oistrakh, Perlman, Bernstein, Rubinstein, Horowitz, Barenboim, Zuckerman, Stern, Milstein and Menuhin are the elite tip of the iceberg, to which we can add all the musicians and artists of Terezin in WWII, and Mahler himself. Why have so many Italian Scots emerged in recent years as prominent artists – Nicola Benedetti, Paolo Nutini, Peter Capaldi, Lewis Capaldi, Tom Conti etc?
On a personal note, where did my voice come from? There is no trace in my family history of vocal talent, and yet by 15 I knew that I had a voice unlike anyone else I knew, a voice that has been my defining feature since then!
Interestingly, my own son has inherited my speaking voice, and may have some aspects of my singing voice, although he has kept that hidden for 35 years! I was not really aware of my unique speaking voice until quite recently, when at a reunion of old friends from the Guildhall School of Music 50 years ago several people mentioned their delight in hearing me speak after all these years, and made clear that, as well as my singing voice, my speaking voice was a major part of what they remembered about the young me.
I appreciate that this is all down to genes, and is not disputed, but the extraordinary profusion of world class Jewish instrumentalists over a relatively short period, the amazing appearance of some of the greatest composers of all time coming out of Germany and the Austro-Hungarian Empire from the mid-18th to the late 19th century, and the scarcely credible juxtaposition of Michelangelo, Leonardo, Raphael, Botticelli, Mantegna et al in the late Renaissance in northern Italy, is not so easily explained.
From Mozart, Haydn and Beethoven, through Schubert, Schumann and Brahms, through Wagner, Bruckner, Liszt and Mahler, to Strauss, Berg and Schönberg, the rota of world class composers makes astonishing reading. Why did they all appear at nearly the same time? Similarly, Keats, Shelley, Wordsworth, Byron all flourished around the same time. Why?
How much of, say, James Botham’s success was due to the fact that his father was a footballer and his grandfather one of the great cricketers? How can one explain the geographical coincidence of these composers and painters, and the genetic nature of all those instrumentalists?
I have no answers but it’s fun to speculate. I would be interested to hear our readers’ views on this.