Stuttgart Philharmonic with Alim Beisembayev

Usher Hall 18/11/26

Stuttgart Philharmonic Mariano Chiacchiarini conductor, Alim Beisembayev piano


Stuttgart Philharmonic's concert is the first of five in a whistle-stop UK tour over six nights. Edinburgh audiences are conservative when it comes to concert days – Thursdays, Fridays and Sunday afternoons are fine, but this Wednesday concert has proved a difficult sell; nevertheless a pretty full Grand Circle and a respectable Stalls audience are in for a treat as they greet the Orchestra processing on stage, continental style, for Mendelssohn's 'Hebrides Overture'.

The sound conductor Mariano Chiacchiarini and his forces produce are immediately compelling, with strength right through all sections. Mendelssohn wrote about his unpleasant time at sea on the boat to Fingal's Cave, and the overture begins with a turbulent passage giving the winds and timpani their time in the limelight. With a large contingent of lower strings, they and the fine bassoonists provide a terrific bass line for this drama. But Mendelssohn also loved his visit to the Hebrides, and cheerful gurgling and rippling from the higher winds and strings reflect calmer seas and enjoyment.

A chamber-sized orchestra re-forms while the piano is pushed on for Mozart's Piano Concerto No 20. Clarinets depart as well as timpani and some upper and lower strings. We are lucky to have this chance to hear Alim Beisembayev. From Kazakhstan, with early tuition there and in Russia, he later studied in the US and was, at the age of 25, still pursuing a course at the Royal Academy of Music when he won the Leeds Piano Competition in 2021. This and his 2023 Proms debut (like tonight a replacement for an indisposed pianist) set him on his way to fame – The Telegraph recently named him “one of the top ten musicians in the world.” Composed in 1785 shortly before Don Giovanni, the concerto shares the same key and a similar sense of turbulence and sometimes conflict. The orchestra, with trumpets, timpani and horns dominating, starts plays a challenging theme, with the piano entry nearly 3 minutes in. The orchestra stops while the piano plays an unrelated more gentle melody. This initial pattern develops into a more equal, though never fully amicable exchange with the pianist picking up, echoing or continuing the orchestra's part – and sometimes vice versa. Both orchestra and pianist bring out this uneasiness, which finds its fullest expression in the long cadenza, in which harrumphing twirls on the lower notes alternate with an exploration of a new tune in the higher notes. Beisembayev is not a showy player, focussing his energy, as Mozart requires, on the precise playing and sound quality of every note.

The fine slow movement Romanze in which trumpets and drums take a rest, is quietly co-operative, the theme set out by the piano with the orchestra joining in. A surprisingly abrasive middle section features two horns, while the pianist's hands rush up and down the keyboard. The Romanze's quiet conclusion flows almost directly into the rapid piano opening to the Allegro assai third movement. Much of the Mozart we hear today, live or recorded is played on period instruments, so this orchestra's modern horns, trumpets and timpani provides a different take on the concerto's big moments. There are plenty in this stirring conclusion, and the pianist enjoys his chance to erupt into brilliance especially in the thrilling cadenza, which unexpectedly moves into the major key to provide a cheerful end to the concerto. Timothy Dowlings's excellent online programme notes compare this to the end of 'Don Giovanni# where, after all the trauma, Leporello has the last laugh! Loud applause results in an encore - a very fast sonata, perhaps by Scarlatti. Its intricacies astound us. For the second time in a week, (after Sheku Kanneh-Mason last Thursday) I've heard a truly great musician in the Usher Hall

Brahms 1883 Symphony No 3 calls for the Orchestra's full resources. 60 players take the stage, clarinets return with two more two horns, and three trombones. These provide a full brass sound with the horns in this exciting opening movement. Chiacchiarini has a fine grasp of the structure of this 35 minute work, in which alternating dynamic and more restrained passages can lead to loss of momentum. He ensures a warm tone in the Andante, which includes passages for the trombones and also a repeated horn call. In place of the expected scherzo, Brahms has an interesting poco allegretto which begins with a bright waltz-like opening, bassoons and flutes swaying along. The principal horn player has a lovely solo in the trio before the movement slows into a funeral march. The vigour of the allegro finale is interrupted by a poco sostenuto sombre chorale for wind instruments, and, instead of a bold conclusion, this movement, like the other three, ends quietly.

The applause, however, is loud and we are treated to not one but two exciting encores, of which the first is the best known of Brahms Hungarian Dances - the Stuttgart players and the audience all now smiling.


https://cultureedinburgh.com/api/media/file/Stuttgart%2018%20November%20Programme.pdf‍ ‍

Kate Calder

Kate was introduced to classical music by her father at SNO Concerts in Kirkcaldy.  She’s an opera fan, plays the piano, and is a member of a community choir, which rehearses and has concerts in the Usher Hall.

Next
Next

Saltire Society 90th Anniversary Concert