Edinburgh City Orchestra

Queen’s Hall 15/11/26

Edinburgh City Orchestra, Peter Le Tissier conductor, Rock Lee leader

Catriona Mackenzie piano

The Edinburgh City Orchestra (ECO) opened their fifth season of music with a challenging programme inspired by mythology, folklore and romanticism. They began with Carl Maria von Weber’s ‘Der Freischütz Overture’ followed by Beethoven’s Piano Concerto no. 3 and Dvořák’s Symphony no. 9 ‘From the New World’. This is an amateur orchestra of largely younger players with a community ethos and a professional sound. The Queen’s Hall was around two-thirds full with a relaxed atmosphere as players waved to friends and family in the audience and chatted to them at the interval.

Invitation orchestras such as ECO are assembled from local musicians who do not perform in full time ensembles but nevertheless enjoy the opportunity for public performance. For example, Andrea Jardine is a registered music therapist who played in ECO for three years. The orchestra was founded by Artistic Director Peter Le Tissier with leader Rock Lee, who met when they were both studying at Royal Holloway University of London. Peter had previously established the Surbiton Symphony Orchestra in 2018, which has performed works by 19th and early 20th century composers such as Beethoven, Wagner, Tchaikovsky and Mahler. These musical choices reflect the focus of his research for his MMus.

Weber’s ‘Der Freischütz Overture’ is a narrative tone poem, summarising the opera it precedes. It starts very softly with the first theme a challenge for the horn players. Cellos enter to add depth and tension and excitement builds when winds introduce a new theme. This is developed across the piece and builds to a glorious conclusion. Of course, an amateur orchestra won’t achieve the same precision as a professional one, especially in quieter passages, but the ECO sounds great when they play loudly, with good balance across the sections.

Reflecting my own prejudices, I might expect a conductor of romantic music to have an energetic, flamboyant style, with large arm movements, embodying the musical emotion. Peter Le Tissier has a more restrained style but nevertheless draws great feeling from the orchestra.

Catriona Mackenzie took the stage for the Beethoven concerto. She was wearing an off-the-shoulder clinging purple dress, perhaps channelling Yuja Wang, although my audience neighbour suggested that piano solos are hot work and she just needed to be cool. Her playing was assured with clear articulation and a lovely tone. This concerto is often cited as marking a turning point between classical and romantic styles. It opens with an introduction shared between the wind and string sections. The theme in the wind instruments floated clearly over the hall but things got a bit muddy when taken up by the strings. Once she entered, the soloist seemed to draw from them a good balance and a pleasing sound. She displayed considerable expertise in the cadenza with assured strong runs and chords across the full range of the piano, dropping to delicate high trills before the theme returns and repeats with rich ornamentation. The slow second movement was more challenging for the orchestra but the soloist brought out its melancholic, romantic nature. The final rondo contains classical contrapuntal textures interspersed with fiery aggression, before coming to a bright boisterous close. Following rapturous applause, the audience was treated to a moving rendition of Peter Maxwell-Davies ‘Farewell to Stromness’.

During the interval, I got the chance to chat to Peter Le Tissier briefly. He came across as a quietly enthusiastic musician and teacher, committed to getting the best out of his players. He feels at home with the amateur orchestra, in which many of the players are moving on from their studies at the Conservatoire. He can already identify those who will be able to progress further. For the Dvořák symphony, he knows there is a range of experience with the piece, some having played it ten times, whereas to others it is new. He was looking forward to bringing them to the highest level they are capable of.

This final piece certainly seemed to be the most assured of the concert. The opening chords were suitably tense although exposed and somewhat tenuous. Once the whole ensemble came together, they had a melodic and robust sound, bringing out the nostalgia of the first movement. The second movement features the well-known largo on cor anglais with strings taking up the melody in a more wistful frame. A second theme seemed to be questioning: how do you really feel about this? This ran more urgently through the strings until a burst of bird song broke out to take us to a happier place. The third movement contains one of Dvořák’s Bohemian Dances, whose complex cross rhythms were challenging for the orchestra. In the final movement, themes from the first three return before two horns rush the music to its dramatic conclusion.

Overall the programme was well chosen to match the strengths of the ECO. This romantic repertoire is accessible to friends and family, who might only have attended to support the players, but would be encouraged to attend other concerts.

Olwyn Alexander

Olwyn Alexander has survived two careers as a research chemist and a university teacher of English to international students and now enjoys a role as a tour guide in the Royal Mile and New Town. She is interested in a wide variety of musical styles and genres and the crossover between them.

Next
Next

Schumann’s Piano Concerto