Schumann’s Piano Concerto

Usher Hall 13/11/26

Royal Scottish National Orchestra

Thomas Søndergård (Conductor)

Anna Vinnitskaya (Piano)


Having missed last week’s Verdi Requiem through illness, I was delighted to be back at the Usher Hall for this interesting programme. The RSNO is about to embark on a short but busy tour of Germany and Austria next week, taking in six cities and playing three programmes, all conducted by the orchestra’s Musical Director, Thomas Søndergård. To prepare for this, Scotland’s three main cities are seeing different overlapping programmes this week, and Edinburgh’s concert offered Dorothy Howell’s tone poem, ‘Lamia’, Schumann’s Piano Concerto and Elgar’s First Symphony. Apparently, all the concerts on tour are sold out (a marvellous testament to the growing renown of our national orchestra), and the Usher Hall had a very satisfactory audience on Friday. The concert was sponsored by the RSNO’s new Partner in Innovation, the semiconductor supplier, Cirrus Logic, demonstrating the important part that corporate sponsorship can play in modern music making throughout the world.

The concert tonight began with an amazing tone poem, based on Keats’ 1820 poem, ‘Lamia’, by the precocious English composer, Dorothy Howell. Introduced by Sir Henry Wood in one of his Prom concerts at the Albert Hall in 1919, ‘Lamia’ seems to have taken the London musical world by storm. Howell was a recent graduate of the Royal Academy of Music, only 21, and a woman, and the post war audience in London was utterly astonished by the virtuoso writing of this new phenomenon. She was acclaimed as the English Strauss, although I found her inspiration, to my ears anyway, more clearly from Ravel and Rimsky-Korsakov. There is certainly no doubt that Miss Howell possessed a clear and ravishing skill in orchestration, and I was surely not alone in marvelling at this delightful piece, albeit based on a rather weird and somewhat gruesome Greek legend. It is written in a high Romantic style, dripping with chromaticism, and she conjured marvellous sounds out of the orchestra, played to the hilt by the RSNO, and featuring a lovely oboe solo by Adrian Wilson.

The Usher Hall Steinway was rolled on, and soon we were able to greet the superb Russian pianist, Anna Vinnitskaya, winner of the 2005 Queen Elisabeth Competition, to play the Schumann Piano Concerto, the fruit of much labour by the already ailing composer. Encouraged by his wife Clara, herself one of the great virtuoso pianists of the middle of the 19th century, Robert Schumann wrote one of his most romantic and thrilling orchestral pieces, a suitable vehicle for his wonderful wife, and it was played absolutely brilliantly by Anna Vinnitskaya. Wearing a stunning long pink skirt, she dominated the performance right from the outset, where Schumann introduces the soloist with a bravura flourish. One imagines that Clara must have been delighted to play such a great piece written specially for her, and Ms Vinnitskaya played with heart and soul, as well as technical brilliance. I’ve not heard better piano playing for a long time, dramatic and forceful when needed, but dreamy and ethereal at other times. Her total command of the keyboard, and obvious enjoyment too, superbly supported by Mr Søndergård, made the concerto fly by. There were many highlights – the lovely duet between piano and Timothy Orpen’s clarinet in the first movement, the interplay between cellos, violas and the piano in the second Intermezzo movement, and the headlong charge to the end of the finale, producing a spontaneous burst of applause from the audience. A wistful encore of ‘Von fremden Ländern und Menschen’ from Schumann’s ‘Kinderszenen’ was an inspired choice, sending us all off to our interval drinks smiling.

After the interval, Thomas Søndergård and the RSNO played Edward Elgar’s First Symphony, and it proved to be another inspired choice. Having been bombarded at school by the pomp and circumstance side of Elgar, this composer has always been problematic for me, sending me scurrying to the delights of Ralph Vaughan Williams instead. However, certain works really appeal to me – the Cello Concerto, The Apostles and the symphonies - and this performance of the First was thrilling and magnificent. From the beginning and the first revelation of the Great Theme, the work unfolded over just under an hour of beautifully constructed symphonic music, played here with relish and flair by the RSNO. All the sections were in terrific form, with ravishing playing from the woodwind in particular, and I must commend the Leader, Igor Yuzefovich, for his masterful playing of the extended violin solo part. The majestic first movement was played with vigour and elan, and when the perpetuum mobile of the second movement started, the strings were absolutely together in their quicksilver scurrying. The Adagio is the heart of the symphony, and its long-spun melody was beautifully played. Apparently, it so excited the first night audience in Manchester in 1908, that their applause forced the composer to take a bow then and there. The finale begins with a slow introduction, but soon builds to a vibrant climax, leading to the triumphant return of the Great Theme and the glorious end. The ovation was warm and prolonged, and we can only hope that the Germans and Austrians next week find it as revelatory!

Brian Bannatyne-Scott

Brian is an Edinburgh-based opera singer, who has enjoyed a long and successful international career.

Next
Next

SCO: Sheku Kanneh-Mason plays Haydn