City Halls Glasgow 15/11/26
BBCSSO, Kalena Bovell (conductor), Oleg Shebeta-Dragan (clarinet)
I was back to Glasgow’s City Halls on the of 15th November for another afternoon “basket of goodies” programme from the BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra’s 2026-27 season. Panamanian-American conductor Kalena Bovell conducted the orchestra in three ever-popular masterworks. The headline piece was Mozart's evergreen Clarinet Concerto with Ukrainian clarinettist Oleg Shebeta-Dragan as soloist. It was preceded by Rimsky-Korsakov's colourful ‘Capriccio espagnol’. After the interval, Bartók’s wonderfully atmospheric ‘Concerto for Orchestra’ put the orchestra through its paces. The concert was recorded for broadcast on ‘Radio 3 in Concert’ on 23 November. The programme was introduced, for both the hall and the recording, by Gillian Moore, with whose series ‘Key Changes: Radio 3's Essential History of Classical Music’ it links. Both ‘Radio 3 in Concert’ and ‘Key Changes’ are available to listen on BBC Sounds. Attendance was entirely satisfactory. Our guest leader for the afternoon was Lucy Gould, founder violinist of the Gould Piano Trio. Rather unusually, the conductor’s rehearsal stool had been left on the podium, but she worked around it uninhibited and it was removed after the Rimsky.
A carnival atmosphere is the predominant mood of the Capriccio and its opening Alborada was gleefully festive, with two early glittering solos from Yann Ghiro’s clarinet and Lucy Gould’s violin. It was the horn section’s turn to shine in presenting the songlike melody of the Variazioni, radiantly taken up by the strings, with some more solos from James Horan’s cor anglais and Chris Gough’s horn, before a richer variation for full orchestra. After a reprise of the Alborada, the fanfares (for trumpets and horns), followed by cadenzas based on them for solo violin, flute (Matthew Higham), clarinet and harp (Helen Thomson), of the Scena evoked pageantry. These led to the flair of flamenco in the Canto gitano, a lively dance. The party atmosphere reigned in the wild Fandango asturiano, its faster coda driving the Alborada’s theme to a pyrotechnic finish. Kalena Bovell’s reading of the Capriccio revealed every thrilling detail of Rimsky-Korsakov's score, and she had willing accomplices in the players of the orchestra. I want to praise the composer’s “orchestration”, but he rather famously insisted that the Capriccio was not “orchestrated” (in the sense of “conceived in short score and then fleshed out for full score”) – it was conceived as a piece for orchestra as an organic whole. No better band for realising it, I’d say, and they were on top form. As a showcase of an orchestra, the Capriccio is a great concert-opener.
Oboes being absent from Mozart’s score for his last major work, the orchestra tuned unusually from the principal bassoon. Their introduction set the sunny A-major mood nicely. The timbre and idiomatic Mozartian phrasing of the ornamented solo entry were delicious, as was the subsequent concertante dialogue with the orchestra, through the genial exposition and the key exploration of the development. The “cloud shadow” moments of the minor key interludes were elegantly pointed, while the mini-cadenzas were stylish. Though the first movement is a delight and the most substantial of the three, it is always the idyllic D-major Adagio that comes to mind when I think of the piece. Two cantabile 8-bar phrases, each introduced by the soloist and repeated by the orchestra, comprise the main theme. The second of these has a charm and tenderness that make it a candidate for the title of “most achingly beautiful moment in all music” (possibly rivalled by a similar moment in the Clarinet Quintet) and it received a spellbinding realisation that fully advocated for that candidacy. The more rhapsodic central section and its short cadenza were very stylish, with some gorgeous visits to the rich timbre of the lower chalumeau register of the instrument. There was exquisite stillness in the pianissimo reprise of the main theme, with a modified solo ornamentation of that magical second phrase, answered “straight” by the hushed orchestra. Perfect. The jaunty A-major 6/8 of the sonata-rondo finale enjoyed the ideal tempo for its agile dancing playfulness to shine. There was a mood of mischief, which was enhanced with the joyful burbling arpeggiation at which the clarinet excels, some teasing tenuti and a few cheeky pauses in the ritornelli. An altogether gleeful close to an optimal outing for the Mozart then, very well received by the enthusiastic Glasgow audience. There was an unfamiliar surprise encore. The orchestral leader was joined by the principals of the second violins (Lise Aferiat), violas (guest Jane Atkins) and cellos (Rudi De Groote), with Oleg Shebeta-Dragan, in a performance of a miniature for clarinet quintet, possibly a slow movement of a larger piece for that ensemble, or possibly an arrangement of a piece for other instrumentation. It had a mid-to-late 19th century feel. If I had to guess, I would say Fanny Mendelssohn or Max Bruch, though really it carried a different voice and its brevity took it further from either of those styles. It was very lovely and well-received.
Few pieces can set out an orchestra’s credentials as unambiguously as Bartók’s Concerto, with ample scope to display sectional virtuosity and playful musicality. Under Kalena Bovell’s direction, this potential was fully realised. The lower string sound in the mysterious opening was spellbinding; the anguished response of the upper strings impassioned and dramatic. The Allegro vivace was agile and characterful, the brass fugato section as thrilling as ever. I had been musing all afternoon about how Kalena Bovell’s tempi had consistently stemmed from logic that eschewed any momentary thrill of speed where it would later cause an exquisite detail to be obscured. The whimsical second movement of the Bartók rewards breathing space for the playful pairings in the scoring, each pair with its own melody separated by a different fixed interval. Pairs of bassoons, oboes, clarinets, flutes and trumpets took their turns in the spotlight over spooky shimmering strings and the rhythmic tapping of a snareless side drum. The movement pivots around a delicious brass chorale in the middle, warmly lyrical before returning to the game of pairs. The spooky elegiac night-music of the third movement was delivered with the utmost mastery. The Interrupted Intermezzo, where an idyllic Lehár quotation is interrupted by a parody of the ostinato from the first movement of Shostakovich’s 7th Symphony, complete with heckling from the brass and derisive laughter and raspberries from the winds, was an absolute hoot. The trombone glissandi were the best I’ve heard. The tempo for the Presto was fast enough to be exciting and virtuosic, but with every exuberant life-affirming detail clear and pointed to perfection, earning thunderous applause from the Glasgow audience. An unforgettable outing for a masterpiece. It is perhaps a selfish thing, but I derive great satisfaction from when a conductor appears to place particular value on the same features of a score as I do.
And, while I appear to be permitting myself a degree of self-indulgent latitude, I’ll add a final remark on the topic of guest leaders. My regular readers will be aware that, since the sad loss of Laura Samuel, the BBCSSO has welcomed a series of illustrious guest leaders, and I have continued to record their names in my reviews. Not a single one has been anything less than an asset to the music-making and the partnership of orchestra and conductor. But I want to record here that, just this once with Lucy Gould, I felt that we had found a perfect fit. I don’t know whether there is a long-term plan, much less what it might be, but if it were a quest and if it were my quest, it would be concluded happily now.
Link: https://www.bbc.co.uk/events/e8c9hn